X

Welcome to the new Leftos.com!

Click here to learn more about the new features and upgrades we've made!

The Engagement

  • dragonfly

    Keeping it a secret

    I sort of like the idea because I can see the value. But I don't know if it's going to be totally practical. I think it would work only if getting engaged and planning on being married was something you were discussing for a while. But mostly, I think it would cause some problems. Chances are one of the two, probably the one being asked, is going to be so excited that she'll want to tell everyone and asking her to be secretive about it for a while doesn't lead to a whole lot of security that the one asking was so sure of wanting to get married in the first place.more

    dragonfly - Answer to the question "Secret Engagements?" - one day ago

  • StillFiguringItOut

    Sounds like a great idea.

    This sounds like a great idea. Ideally one would have explored a lot of these questions as part of getting to know someone; but to agree on the intent to get married seems like an excellent way to give two people a mutual purpose (and perhaps deadline) to put them into the mindset to explore these questions seriously and concretely. more

    StillFiguringItOut - Answer to the question "Secret Engagements?" - 3 days ago

  • RelaxIt

    Unbelievable idea.

    This is why I love this site...I'm always learning great new things. This is an unbelievable idea. The worst thing about engagements is they are overblown. They aren't the wedding, they are just an agreement. And you're completely right, if you get cold feet, how do you back out after an entire party and dinner was thrown just for the engagement. The hardest part is finding out if your partner is down with that too. Some girls have engagements built up in their minds just like weddings. Hollywood has definitely made them into these fairytale scenarios.more

    RelaxIt - Answer to the question "Secret Engagements?" - 4 days ago

  • scarlettewiththerope

    Love it!

    Love it! Never would have occurred to me, but that's very clever.more

    scarlettewiththerope - Answer to the question "Secret Engagements?" - 4 days ago

  • sexpert

    Secret Engagements?

    So my parents will have been together for 30 years this fall, and they have been together through thick and thin, and there has been a lot of thin. They had a very controversial engagement because my mother was a single 22 yo with a baby, and my 32 yo father and her had only been dating a couple months when he popped the question (he was not the father of the baby). The kid that wasn't his, the age difference, and the short time dating made for it to be a little bit of a controversial engagement. Anyway, to the actual point, when my parents got engaged, they talk to the pastor at the church that they met at. The pastor said to try being engaged, but to not tell anyone. Just to have the agreement between each other for a month, and see how it felt. It was like a trial engagement, try it on for size for a month, risk-free, money back guarantee. My parents actually swear by this. Sometimes people get caught up in the proposal, and the excitement, and then after it starts to die down, the worries start to creep in, or you realize that knot in your stomach might be something more than just nerves. It's hard to undo something that you've already told everyone about. Or, better yet, at the end of the month you could feel really comfortable and confident in your decision. Perhaps this would be the better place emotionally to be in when you tell everyone else your good news? It also has the benefit of giving you the opportunity to talk. A lot of people (at least in my observation, feel free to disagree) rush into a decision about getting married based on gut feelings and forget to thoroughly discuss what marriage would look like. How many kids? What size house? What would be grounds for divorce? Should there be a pre-nup? If kids are in the future, when? And will one partner be a stay at home parent, or continue to work? There are so many logistics when it comes to marriage, I think some people wait to have these conversations. Having a delayed announcement of an engagement might give you the opportunity to have these important conversations (and have them be more concrete than "wouldn't it be nice if"). So what do you guys think of delaying the announcement of engagement? I have also heard this being called "engaged to be engaged" where there are plans to get married, but it's not official yet. What do you think? Would you be happy doing it this way if you partner suggested this to you?more

    sexpert - Question in The Engagement - 4 days ago

    Answers 2 | 2

  • sexpert

    I have several that would work for me. ...

    I have several that would work for me. Proposing at a sport's game with everyone there to share in the moment of "amazing" would be cool. There is just something about having a couple thousand people clap for you and smiling at you because of this very special moment in your life - it just seems right. Chances are, if it comes to this, I will already have made the lifetime commitment in my head, and getting engaged is more about sharing that joy with other people. Then again, any proposal that seems very personal, including going to our favourite restaurant, or recreating a first date or something, that would also work. I just want someone to show that they have put thought into how to do it. When I was younger I had a bf propose to me in a car while we were driving down a road, and I was crying and having a shit day and he said "I know what will make you feel better!" and then proposed. No ring, no speech, no presentation no nothing. I felt ripped off. Although I said yes, I didn't consider ourselves engaged. Nice to know that those were his intentions, but I was not going to run home and tell my mom "hey mom, my bf proposed to me in the car because I'm having a fight with my friend". But everyone is different. It's an intensely personal thing. My suggestion for your friends that are going to pop the question - go through the best friends. The best friends will know all, or will be able to spy for you and figure it out. Hope everything turns out well for your buddies.more

    sexpert - Answer to the question "Popping the Question" - 39 days ago

  • scarlettewiththerope

    Personally, I don't have one. I have a f...

    Personally, I don't have one. I have a few reasons why... It's for two main reasons. The first is that I'm not at a point in my life where I can imagine me and marriage in the same sentence, lol. The second is kinda a principle-of-the-thing. I don't believe in having an ideal/dream proposal scenario, because it just seems like something that should be so personal to the members of the couple that you could only dream about it when you were dreaming about that person. I feel like there are some girls who have some stock scenario and are looking to plug the best fit man into that scenario, and that just annoys me on an elemental level. I feel like that's missing the point somehow.more

    scarlettewiththerope - Answer to the question "Popping the Question" - 39 days ago

  • Fork in Road

    Popping the Question

    Ladies...what is your dream scenario for getting popped the big question, "will you marry me?" Would you prefer it be a big extravaganza? Something nonchalant? When I asked my wife to marry me I didn't do anything that would seem special to outsiders but to us it was perfect. I took her out to our favorite fancy dinner joint in a cute little old fashion town that we once in a while would go to. There was a little waterfall and stream in the middle of the downtown area and after dinner we walked there and I asked her in front of that. It just felt good. I have a couple buddies right now who are considering popping the question and we were discussing how they should do it. We were wondering, what would a girl ideally want if she could choose how it went down?more

    Fork in Road - Question in The Engagement - 39 days ago

    Answers 2 | 0